The renewalofcollective industrial land with the transformation of village industrial park as the main object is an important force for the development of stock land and the transformation of urban economy.Based on the logical model evaluation framework, a four-dimension evaluation conceptual model of resource input-action response-outcome output-comprehensive benefit was constructed. Qualitative analysis was adopted to evaluate the overall effectiveness of village level industrial park renewal by comprehensively using departmental statisticaldata, literature and field research data. Based on the evaluation conclusion, policy recommendations are proposed as follows.In order to promote the transformation of village-level industrial parks to achieve high-quality development, investment channels should be expanded, long-term overall planning should be strengthened, precise investment should be implemented, governance mechanisms should beinnovated, and disordered competition should be restrained by policy guidance.